A beloved island gem is entering a new era. Muddy Toes Café, a cozy fixture of Tangier Island’s tight-knit community, is now under new ownership and management, marking the end of an era for founders Brigitte, Catherine, and Debi — and the beginning of a fresh chapter for the café that has served as much more than just a coffee stop.
In an announcement shared this week, the original owners expressed heartfelt gratitude to the residents of Tangier and visitors alike who made the café a cherished local institution. “This little café has been more than a business to us — it’s been a place of connection, laughter, and community,” they wrote. “From early morning coffee chats to summer afternoons with cones in hand, we’ve been lucky to share it all with you.”
Muddy Toes Café has been a staple for both year-round residents and seasonal tourists, offering comforting fare and a welcoming atmosphere in the heart of the Chesapeake Bay. Over the years, it has become a favorite stop for early risers grabbing coffee, families cooling off with ice cream cones, and anyone in need of a quiet moment on the porch.
While details about the new owners have yet to be made public, the original team encouraged customers to stay tuned through the café’s new Facebook page for updates, new offerings, and hours. The transition aims to preserve the spirit of the café while offering fresh ideas for the next chapter of its story.
The former owners emphasized that although they are stepping away from day-to-day operations, they are not leaving the island. “We still have a home here and will remain part of this incredible island community,” they said.
Muddy Toes Café’s evolution reflects the enduring strength of Tangier Island itself — a place where tradition and resilience walk hand in hand. As new leadership takes the helm, islanders and visitors alike are eager to see how the café continues to serve as a gathering place for stories, friendships, and the simple joy of a good cup of coffee.
For updates, events, and announcements, community members are encouraged to follow Muddy Toes Café’s new Facebook page.
Tangier Island, Virginia 